LTD Management
Logistics & Supply Chain Management Consulting Solutions That Work
Portuges

STRATEGY FOR LOGISTICS SERVICE PROVIDERS

All logistics providers-3PLs, transport, forwarders, warehouses, logistics centers, ports and other--and whether they are asset based or non-asset based should have a strategy. The strategy identifies challenges, issues and risks with markets and their dynamics; and, going forward, can set the direction where the company is going for new markets and new business and customers to grow sales and profits.

Surprisingly, despite the purpose and benefit, many service providers do not have a viable, current strategy. Instead they view developing one as too much work, react to what customers ask or what competitors are doing, or have one that is outdated. In a way, they letting business vagaries drive their direction and future. Having no strategy can be a risky approach, especially if competitors, established and the potential new entrants, have a well-done strategy and especially given the reality of global economic change.

The strategy can be operations focused or it can be a significant change, to transform the company. Which strategy is developed can be based on and reflect risks for the business or for the service sector, competition, or changing customer and/or market segments.

There are two parts to a successful strategy-first, developing one and second, executing it. Developing a strategy comes from serious, formal strategic planning process. It involves a blend of financial and non-financial objectives. The plan should also focus on the present business, and how it will adapt to the future and new services and opportunities. It identifies where the company is going--and where it is not going-- and what it takes to succeed in that service arena.

Planning. The starting point is where the business is now as to present dynamics with trends, markets, services, and customers; value proposition, and competitive positioning, coupled with sales and profits. At any stage of the planning process, at the minimum, a SWOT (Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats) is useful for the present and potential future scenarios.

Planning contains mistakes that can limit the ability to develop a worthwhile strategic plan. Some of the shortcomings that can lead to a bad strategy include:

There are basically three approaches for logistics service providers to strategically differentiate themselves-

  1. Status quo. The conservative, stay-the-course option may seem like the safest choice; but it carries significant risk in the ever-changing and competitive global economy. Executives with strong risk aversion favor this way. It depends on the past to predict the future and on simplified assumptions to assume away uncertainty.
  2. Organic growth. This can be a slow and assumed steady method using internal capabilities and resources. The approach implies high expectations and requires improved performance.
  3. Aggressive growth. External partnerships or alliances and, especially, merger and acquisition are options with this choice. In addition to identifying right target firm, timing is an issue with this choice.

Companies, whether using organic and aggressive, can pursue one strong initiative or a few worthy opportunities. These approaches mean there will be an allocation, even reallocation, of resources--capital, people, assets and technology.

Going forward, firms should adapt and change their present businesses and build new ones. Companies should both change existing services and create fresh service offerings. It is not an either-or as to adapt or create; it is to do both, unless the plan involves divestiture or maximize profits of the present service and let it fade away.

Execution. Strategy implementation is critical. The best strategy, without good execution, will struggle to succeed. And the more dramatic the strategy is with scope and impact, the greater is the challenge for sound execution. An operations strategy has an internal capabilities and requirements, perhaps best-in-class. The significant change strategy has both internal and external requirements. Each strategy carries different proficiencies to implement and creates challenges for present executives, managers and employees to have the skills to implement the strategy.

Achieving the strategy separates planning for the sake of planning and planning needed to advance into the future. It also demonstrates the conviction that the company has in the strategy. Executing the strategy means communicating the plan within the company and with stakeholders to build support-both operating and financial--and aligning the business with its strategy. Adequate resources and defined responsibilities for execution are needed, along with corresponding, relevant metrics to track progress.

The transformation and its rate of implementation to carry out the strategy may require recognizing and dealing with the need for change management. In reality, there are strong similarities between change management and successfully implementing a strategy.

Tied to the grand strategy are underlying strategies and implementation plans for sales, pricing, marketing, positioning, operations and technology. Logistics providers should recognize the life cycle to their services, especially with regard to profit maximization and the commodity service view of their offerings. This service life cycle creates the need for the subset of strategies and fulfillment of them. How people within the company grasp and execute these opportunities can have significant effect on long-term margins.

While direction can come from the top level, carrying out the execution needs clear lines of responsibilities couple with a coordinated, cross functional effort by different groups within the company. There can be no standalone activities for success. It should be integrated. The potential for assuming away the need for the collaboration can create unnecessary surprises and failure to gain all the market, operations and financial benefits of the strategy.

Strategy planning and execution are not easy for logistics providers. They are a challenge. But as difficult as they are, doing nothing in the face of dynamic competitive and market changes can be dangerous for all stakeholders. Logistics providers that do not plan well and implement well let events drive where they are going. They do not control it. These providers are market followers, not market leaders. As a result, these firms do not transition to take full advantage of opportunities. They miss out on market share, customers and profits that companies, who have a coordinated planning and strategy execution, earn and enjoy.